|
Minnesota Crop News > 2001-2008 Archives
September
17, 2004
Zinc
Fertilization in Minnesota: A Review
George
Rehm, Dept. of Soil, Water, and Climate
Zinc (Zn), a micronutrient essential for crop growth,
is supplied by the soil to support optimum crop production
in most of Minnesota. However, there are production situations
where this micronutrient, when added to a fertilizer program
will produce profitable increases in crop yield.
Zinc fertilization is not complicated. Of the major crops
grown in this state, corn and dry
edible beans are known to be responsive to zinc
fertilization. Various research trials have been conducted
to evaluate the effect of zinc fertilization on a variety
of crops. Except for the two just mentioned, none have
responded positively to the application of zinc in a fertilizer
program.
Analysis of a soil sample for zinc is
the best management tool available to accurately predict
the need. The soil test for zinc that is used by soil testing
laboratories is built on a solid research base. It is accurate
and reliable. It can be used with confidence. Suggestions
for the amount of Zn to apply vary with the amount of Zn
measured. These suggestions are summarized in Table 1.
Table 1. Zinc suggestions for corn and dry edible
bean production and the relation to the amount of Zn
extracted from the soil.
| ppm |
-
- - - - - lb. Zn/acre - - - - - - |
| |
Band |
Broadcast |
0.0
to 0.25
|
2
|
10
|
| 0.26 to 0.50 |
2 |
10 |
| 0.51 to 0.75 |
1 |
5 |
| 0.76 to 1.00 |
0 |
0 |
* Zn extracted by the DTPA procedure
The suggestions listed in Table 1 are appropriate for
both corn and dry edible bean production. Lower rates are
needed for correction of a Zn deficiency if this micronutrient
is applied in a band at planting rather than broadcast
and incorporated prior to planting.
When the soil test for Zn is low, small amounts applied
in a band can have a positive substantial effect on crop
yield (Table 2). Compared to broadcasting, there is a higher
probability that roots will come in contact with this nutrient
if the zinc fertilizer is applied in a band near the seed
at planting. The cost of the banded zinc is also substantially
less.
Table 2. Response of irrigated corn to Zn fertilization.
| lb./acre |
bu./acre |
| 0 |
62 |
| 0.1 |
130 |
| 1.0 |
139 |
* soil test for Zn = low
The magnitude of the yield increase shown
in Table 2 is not typical of most situations. These results,
however, show how important a micronutrient can be when
it is deficient in the soil. In Minnesota, it is more realistic
to expect increases in corn yields of 10 to 15 bu. per
acre provided the soil test for Zn is in the low range.
There are several sources that can be used to supply
Zn in a fertilizer program. These sources have been compared
using suspension fertilization applied in a band (Table
3). The zinc rate for all sources was constant at 0.5 lb.
Zn per acre. The soil test for Zn was low at both research
sites.
Table 3. Yield of irrigated corn as affected by
the source of Zn applied in a band near the seed at planting.
| |
-
- - - - - bu./acre - - - - - - - - |
EDTA chelate
|
119a |
143a |
| complex |
125a |
133a |
| sulfate |
121a |
137a |
| oxide |
114a |
132a |
In this research, all sources of Zn had an equal effect
on corn yield. There are some perceptions that one source
of Zn is more effective than another. However, research
has shown that, when applied in a band near the seed, all
sources have an equal effect on yield.
Zinc sulfate blends easily with other dry fertilizers.
Therefore, this source would be a good first choice when
the producer is using dry fertilizers in a band at planting.
The solubility of zinc oxide decreases as soil pH increase.
Therefore, this material would not be a good choice for
mixing with dry fertilizers.
The chelated Zn sources and the Zn complex can be mixed
easily with fluid fertilizers such as 10-34-0. Usually
there is a substantial difference in cost of these two
sources. In addition, there may be free ammonia in the
complexes. Therefore, there is a risk in placing fluids
containing a zinc complex in contact with the seed at planting.
The amount of Zn that can be applied in this way is not
known. This is especially true with dry edible beans. It
would be wise to plan on placing any fluid fertilizer containing
a zinc complex near the seed so that there is some soil
between seed and fertilizer.
Zinc is important for crop production in Minnesota. When
needed in a fertilizer program, its use can have a positive
economical impact on production. Crop producers are urged
to test soil for this micronutrient to see if they have
been missing some profit potential.
|