|
Minnesota Crop News > 2001-2008 Archives
July
1, 2004
Impanct of Potash Use for Corn in Southeast Minnesota
Tim Wagar, Regional Extension Educator, Rochester, and George Rehm, Department of Soil, Water, and Climate
Potash has been a key component of fertilizer programs
in southeast Minnesota for many years and rate and placement
guidelines have been in place for some time. Until recently,
however, research and extension programs that focus on
potash fertilization have not been extremely active.
Beginning in the mid-1990’s several trials were
conducted in fields of cooperating farmers to take a renewed
look at potash fertilization practices for corn. It was
especially important because of higher yields, to evaluate
the effectiveness of current fertilizer recommendations.
These trials focused on yield response in relation to soil
test values for potassium (K).
A summary of corn yields from three locations is provided
in Table 1. At all locations, soil samples collected from
0 to 6 inches were collected before the fertilizer was
broadcast. There was no history of manure for any field.
The various rates of potash supplied as 0-0-60, were broadcast
and incorporated before planting.
Table 1. Corn yield in southeastern Minnesota
as affected by a broadcast application of potash fertilizer.
K2O
Rate
Applied |
Location |
Goodhue Co.
|
Dodge Co. |
Fillmore Co. |
lb./acre |
- - - - - - - bu./acre - - -
- - - - - - |
0
50
100
150
200 |
192
190
199
209
206 |
183
185
190
195
198 |
124
178
191
196
201 |
| --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
Soil Test K, ppm |
96 |
136 |
58 |
Using current University of Minnesota definitions the
soil test K values are considered to be medium, high, and
low at the Goodhue, Dodge, and Fillmore County sites respectively.
There is a very good probability that potash fertilizer
will increase yields when soil test K is low. Without adequate
potash, yield was reduced by about 40% at the Fillmore
County site. When soil test K is in the medium range, use
of potash fertilizer may increase corn yield. Without potash
use at the Goodhue County site, yield was reduced by about
7%. A 6% reduction in yield was measured at the Dodge County
site where a high soil test K would indicate a low probability
of a yield increase. Excellent yields were measured at
all sites and this may have affected the response at the
Dodge County site.
The importance of adequate potash fertilization is also
illustrated in Table 2. Corn was grown at a site in Fillmore
County having a low soil test value for K (63 ppm). A broadcast
rate of 150 lb. K2O per acre provided for near
optimum yield. Using a value of $2.75 per bu. of corn and
a price of $.12 per pound of K2O, the value of the additional
corn after subtracting the cost of the fertilizer was $127
per acre. Yields were reduced by about 35% if potash was
not applied.
The soil test values for potassium measured after harvest
also changed with potash fertilization. After subtracting
the amount of K removed by the crop, the soil test for
K changed by 1 ppm for each 7 lb. K2O applied
per acre. Measured changes in soil test values were relatively
small. Much higher rates of potash fertilizer would be
needed to produce higher values following a high corn yield.
Table 2. Corn yield and soil test values (0-6
inches) for potassium as affected by rate of potash applied.
Fillmore County.
K2O |
Corn Yield |
Soil Test
K |
lb. /acre
0
50
100
150
200 |
bu./acre
124
178
191
196
201 |
ppm
63
66
75
81
72 |
Potassium is considered to be an immobile nutrient is
soils and, therefore, efficiency of use should be influenced
by contact between fertilizer and soil. In reducing fixation
or tie-up, banding should be expected to be more efficient
than broadcast applications. Placement comparisons at a
research site in Goodhue County have confirmed the efficiency
of the banded application (Table 3). The initial soil test
value for K at this site was 77 ppm. Clearly, the reduced
rate applied in a band was just as effective, if not more
effective, than a higher rate of potash that was broadcast.
Table 3. Corn yield as affected by rate and placement
of potash fertilizer.
K2O Applied |
Yield |
lb./acre
--
40 lb. K2O/acre, starter
100 lb. K2O/acre, broadcast
200 lb. K2O/acre, broadcast |
bu./acre
114
143
136
140 |
The effectiveness of banded potash fertilizer has also
been demonstrated in fields of cooperating farmers in southeast
Minnesota (Table 4). As with the previous research conducted
in Goodhue County, the efficiency of the banded potash
is obvious.
Table 4. A comparison of banded and broadcast
applications of potash fertilizer for corn production
in southeast Minnesota.
K2O
Applied |
Placement |
Location |
| Goodhue Co. |
Fillmore Co. |
lb./acre |
|
- - - - bu./acre - - -
- |
0
45
105
42
105 |
---
starter
broadcast
starter
broadcast |
137
--
--
180
158 |
132
166
146
--
-- |
| ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
soil test K
(0 to 6 in.), ppm |
|
65 |
less than 80 |
A study of the results of the various projects that have
involved potash fertilization of corn in southeast Minnesota
leads to the following conclusions.
- Highest corn yields are not always associated with
highest soil test values for K. With adequate rates of
potash fertilizer, high yields can be attained even though
soil test values for K might be low (see Table 1).
- When soil test values for K are low and yields are
high, relatively high rates of potash fertilizer are needed
to produce substantial changes in soil test values for
K.
- Banding of potash fertilizer at planting is as efficient
as broadcasting at higher rates. Therefore, the practice
of banding can save money. It is important to include some
potash in the band. For example, use of 10-34-0 in a band
at planting will not be as effective as use of 7-21-7.
Avoid, however, use of high rates of 7-21-7 in contact
with the seed.
The various research projects summarized in the previous
paragraphs show the importance of potash fertilization
for corn production in southeast Minnesota. There is, however,
more research that is needed. Time and dollars can be saved
if potash fertilizer can be applied only once in a crop
rotation. Therefore, studies are needed that will compare
the effects of a single or multiple applications of potash
over a number of years. There is also very little information
that documents the residual effects of large applications
prior to the planting of either corn or alfalfa. If time
and resources are available, research to address these
tow concerns will be started in the near future.
|