Skip to Main navigation Skip to Left navigation Skip to Main content Skip to Footer

University of Minnesota Extension

Extension > Agriculture > Dairy Extension > Farm life > Pennywise rules

Print Icon Email Icon Share Icon

Pennywise rules

Jim Paulson

Pennies per hundredweight trump dollars per cow per year in most years.

What is better for your dairy? Trying to cut expenses by a dollar per cow per year or a nickel per cow per day or a penny per hundredweight? For every hundred cows you milk, you will save $100 for every dollar you cut in production costs per cow. If each of those cows is putting 24,000 pounds of milk in the tank each year, finding one cent per hundredweight in savings will save $240 per 100 cows per year. If you can save $.05 per cow per day in feed costs or other costs, that will add up to $1245 per 100 cows per year.

It does little good, in the face of a cash flow shortfall, to say that you need to be a better manager or become more efficient. You probably are the same manager now as when milk price was $25.00. Most good dairy producers strive to do the best they can every year. What we need is careful examination of the situation we have for 2016 and make some decisions. When cash is short, we might have to make some tough decisions.

Typically, the biggest expense categories for the dairy enterprise are feed, both purchased and farm produced, and labor. Next will usually be depreciation and supplies; but these are generally substantially less, and then followed by vet/drugs and repairs. Other categories make up the balance and may vary slightly from farm to farm. While we call these variable expenses, for the dairy enterprise alone that is holding its size steady, they may be fairly constant with not a lot of room to cut. In times of tight cash, purchased feed and vet/med expenses get cut because they can. But, remember...

Rule #1: "Do not cut anything that cuts milk production." That is usually bad economics. Your focus should be on income over feed costs. That is your margin to pay the other bills. Does it line up with your margin protection plan?

Rule #2: "Don't do anything that will hurt pregnancy rate." Next to feeding and milking, getting cows pregnant is the most important thing you need to do for your dairy to remain profitable. Remember, your goal is 150 days in milk. Lower days in milk usually mean higher milk production and lower feed costs per cwt of milk.

Since feed does represent your largest expense category by far, spend time closely examining how you can lower your feed cost per cwt of milk. The first question is: Do you know what your feed cost is? Work with your nutritionist or other consultants to determine you feed cost.

Rule #3: "Calculate your feed cost per cwt of milk every month." Break that out for the milking cows and then add all animals on the farm. Calculate daily feed cost per head for each group of animals. Then, considering your production and milk price, ask yourself how many dollars of milk per cow per day are going out the door each day? How much is that right now? Is it $12, $13, $14, or more? The next part of the equation is "Is my feed cost per cow per day about half of the value of the milk going out the door per cow each day?"

Rule #4: "The best way to lower feed cost per cwt is to have higher milk production to spread the cost over." (See rule #2) Think about it this way: Have half of your cows at less than 150 days in milk and no cows over 365 days in milk. You are more likely to have higher and more efficient milk production early in lactation.

Rule #5: "The best way to lower purchased feed cost is to have higher quality forage." Remember, your nutritionist is only as good as the forage you give him/her to work with! High quality forage lowers purchased feeds needed and total feed cost, and increases dry matter intake and production. This may also affect your forage mix that you feed your lactating cows. Alfalfa to corn silage ratios influence purchased protein supplement amounts; but digestibility of the forage, whole farm yields and cow preference all need to be taken into consideration.

But the question does come up: Is there anything I can cut out? It is always valuable to look over all the ingredients and their costs. But first think about the fact that if it made sense at $25 milk, it most likely still does at $14 milk as well. Profitable milk production begins with healthy diets, balanced for the level of milk production you want, using your feeds and adding what you need.

What is needed or recommended? There are certain accepted and proven standards for most dairy cattle rations. Greater than 50% forage, preferably more, on a dry matter basis. Adequate fiber, not too high starch, balanced for minerals, protein and including salt, vitamins and trace minerals. But what about additives? Buffers, such as sodium bicarbonate and magnesium oxide are recommended. An organic trace mineral source for zinc, copper, manganese and cobalt in addition to the trace minerals added if organic sources are not already in the vitamin/trace mineral packs. Yeast products of some type are recommended as well to help keep the rumen in a healthy mode. Many herds are also using monensin to improve the efficiency of digestion. All of these products have proven payback. Other additives may be used for certain situations or reasons with a good return, but must be evaluated for response in your herd. Such things as mycotoxin binders, probiotics and enzymes may have been used in the past but need to be re-evaluated periodically. Dry cows, transition cows and fresh cows may have a whole different set of additives and have a good reason to continue. These may include anionic salts, protected choline and others. Similarly, we do not want to cut out vaccinations, deworming, quality milk replacer, heifer and dry cow minerals and many other routine activities. All of these additives do add up. Many may be only five to ten cents per cow per day; in total, they do add up. But trim carefully and be pennywise.

March 2016

  • © Regents of the University of Minnesota. All rights reserved.
  • The University of Minnesota is an equal opportunity educator and employer. Privacy